James McMillan, FW, played for Everton 1890-1896, making 7 appearances and scoring 5 goals.
4 goals in the archive carry James McMillan as the scorer. Coverage of named scorers thins out the further back the record goes.
| Date | Season | Competition | Opponent | Score | Min |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Sep 1893 | 1893–94 | First Division | Nottingham Forest | 4–0 | |
| 4 Sep 1893 | 1893–94 | First Division | Nottingham Forest | 4–0 | |
| 16 Sep 1893 | 1893–94 | First Division | Aston Villa | 4–2 | |
| 7 Apr 1894 | 1893–94 | First Division | Stoke City | 6–2 |