Everton have played Knattspyrnudeild Keflavík 2 times in competitive football, winning 2, drawing 0 and losing 0, first meeting on 16 Sep 1970 and most recently on 30 Sep 1970. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Sep 1970 | 1970–71 | European Cup | H | Knattspyrnudeild Keflavík | 6–2 | Alan Ball Jr 39, Howard Kendall 41, Joe Royle 51, Alan Ball Jr 58, Alan Ball Jr 67, Joe Royle 70 | 28,444 |
| 30 Sep 1970 | 1970–71 | European Cup | A | Knattspyrnudeild Keflavík | 3–0 | Alan Whittle 32, Joe Royle 38, Joe Royle 46 | 9,546 |