Wrexham have played York City 99 times in competitive football, winning 35, drawing 31 and losing 33, first meeting on 4 Sep 1929 and most recently on 25 Mar 2023. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Sep 1929 | 1929–30 | Third Division North | A | York City | 0–0 | ||
| 11 Sep 1929 | 1929–30 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 3 Sep 1930 | 1930–31 | Third Division North | H | York City | 3–2 | ||
| 2 May 1931 | 1930–31 | Third Division North | A | York City | 1–0 | ||
| 26 Sep 1931 | 1931–32 | Third Division North | A | York City | 2–3 | ||
| 6 Feb 1932 | 1931–32 | Third Division North | H | York City | 2–1 | Tommy Bamford 65, Tommy Bamford 70 | |
| 5 Nov 1932 | 1932–33 | Third Division North | A | York City | 3–2 | Tommy Lewis 9, Jackie Hughes 40, Harry Waller 47 | |
| 18 Mar 1933 | 1932–33 | Third Division North | H | York City | 3–1 | Tommy Bamford 6, Jackie Hughes 52, Jackie Hughes 67 | |
| 23 Dec 1933 | 1933–34 | Third Division North | H | York City | 2–3 | Wilson Jones 20, George Frewin 60 | |
| 5 May 1934 | 1933–34 | Third Division North | A | York City | 4–2 | ||
| 27 Oct 1934 | 1934–35 | Third Division North | A | York City | 0–0 | ||
| 9 Mar 1935 | 1934–35 | Third Division North | H | York City | 2–0 | ||
| 2 Nov 1935 | 1935–36 | Third Division North | A | York City | 1–1 | Charlie MacCartney 15 | |
| 7 Mar 1936 | 1935–36 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–0 | Charlie MacCartney 31 | |
| 31 Oct 1936 | 1936–37 | Third Division North | A | York City | 4–3 | Ambrose Brown 9, Ambrose Brown 30, Harold Lapham 47, Harold Lapham 70 | |
| 6 Mar 1937 | 1936–37 | Third Division North | H | York City | 2–0 | ||
| 20 Nov 1937 | 1937–38 | Third Division North | A | York City | 1–2 | George Burditt 55 | |
| 2 Apr 1938 | 1937–38 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–1 | Joe McAleer 50 | |
| 24 Sep 1938 | 1938–39 | Third Division North | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 28 Jan 1939 | 1938–39 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–3 | ||
| 26 Oct 1946 | 1946–47 | Third Division North | H | York City | 3–1 | ||
| 27 May 1947 | 1946–47 | Third Division North | A | York City | 2–2 | ||
| 24 Jan 1948 | 1947–48 | Third Division North | A | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 1 May 1948 | 1947–48 | Third Division North | H | York City | 3–0 | ||
| 9 Oct 1948 | 1948–49 | Third Division North | A | York City | 1–5 | Fred Rowell 42 | |
| 5 Mar 1949 | 1948–49 | Third Division North | H | York City | 3–3 | Billy Tunnicliffe 20, Jack Boothway 49, Dennis Grainger 65 | |
| 24 Sep 1949 | 1949–50 | Third Division North | H | York City | 2–0 | ||
| 4 Feb 1950 | 1949–50 | Third Division North | A | York City | 0–5 | ||
| 9 Sep 1950 | 1950–51 | Third Division North | A | York City | 0–3 | ||
| 13 Jan 1951 | 1950–51 | Third Division North | H | York City | 4–3 | ||
| 8 Dec 1951 | 1951–52 | Third Division North | A | York City | 2–4 | Tommy Bannan 10, Tommy Bannan 12 | |
| 26 Apr 1952 | 1951–52 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 10 Sep 1952 | 1952–53 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 15 Sep 1952 | 1952–53 | Third Division North | A | York City | 1–2 | Ron Hewitt 48 | |
| 10 Oct 1953 | 1953–54 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–1 | Tommy Tilston 62 | |
| 27 Feb 1954 | 1953–54 | Third Division North | A | York City | 2–5 | ||
| 21 Aug 1954 | 1954–55 | Third Division North | H | York City | 2–6 | ||
| 18 Dec 1954 | 1954–55 | Third Division North | A | York City | 3–3 | ||
| 20 Aug 1955 | 1955–56 | Third Division North | A | York City | 3–1 | Eric Littler 61, Ron Hewitt 68, Elfed Evans 75 | |
| 17 Dec 1955 | 1955–56 | Third Division North | H | York City | 4–5 | Gren Jones 10, Gordon Richards 13, Bernard Evans 19, Bernard Evans 56 | |
| 10 Nov 1956 | 1956–57 | Third Division North | H | York City | 1–1 | Ron Hewitt 24 | |
| 23 Mar 1957 | 1956–57 | Third Division North | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 29 Mar 1958 | 1957–58 | Third Division North | A | York City | 2–1 | ||
| 16 Apr 1958 | 1957–58 | Third Division North | H | York City | 2–2 | ||
| 15 Apr 1960 | 1959–60 | Third Division | A | York City | 0–3 | ||
| 18 Apr 1960 | 1959–60 | Third Division | H | York City | 3–1 | Arfon Griffiths 16, Bernard Evans 47, Ron Harbertson 65 | |
| 8 Oct 1960 | 1960–61 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 4–0 | Arfon Griffiths 9, Ron Roberts 12, Wyn Davies 30, Mickey Metcalf 66 | |
| 25 Feb 1961 | 1960–61 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 1–2 | ||
| 21 Aug 1961 | 1961–62 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 2–3 | ||
| 30 Aug 1961 | 1961–62 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 2–1 | ||
| 7 Nov 1964 | 1964–65 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 1–2 | ||
| 20 Mar 1965 | 1964–65 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 2–0 | ||
| 12 Nov 1966 | 1966–67 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 7 Apr 1967 | 1966–67 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 0–4 | ||
| 17 Feb 1968 | 1967–68 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 1–3 | ||
| 11 May 1968 | 1967–68 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 3–1 | ||
| 24 Feb 1969 | 1968–69 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 16 Apr 1969 | 1968–69 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 2–1 | ||
| 6 Sep 1969 | 1969–70 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 4–0 | Albert Kinsey 20, Ray Smith 42, Albert Kinsey 55, Albert Kinsey 74 | |
| 24 Apr 1970 | 1969–70 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 1–2 | ||
| 11 Sep 1971 | 1971–72 | Third Division | A | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 25 Mar 1972 | 1971–72 | Third Division | H | York City | 2–0 | ||
| 30 Sep 1972 | 1972–73 | Third Division | H | York City | 3–1 | ||
| 20 Apr 1973 | 1972–73 | Third Division | A | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 12 Oct 1973 | 1973–74 | Third Division | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 20 Feb 1974 | 1973–74 | Third Division | H | York City | 1–0 | ||
| 1 Nov 1976 | 1976–77 | Third Division | H | York City | 1–1 | Bobby Shinton 80 | |
| 12 Apr 1977 | 1976–77 | Third Division | A | York City | 0–0 | ||
| 1 Nov 1983 | 1983–84 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 2–3 | Andy Edwards 1, Simon Hunt 5 | |
| 28 Feb 1984 | 1983–84 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 0–0 | ||
| 29 Oct 1988 | 1988–89 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 2–1 | ||
| 14 Mar 1989 | 1988–89 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 30 Sep 1989 | 1989–90 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 6 Mar 1990 | 1989–90 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 2–0 | Mark Sertori 53, Roger Preece 62 | |
| 28 Aug 1990 | 1990–91 | League Cup | A | York City | 1–0 | ||
| 4 Sep 1990 | 1990–91 | League Cup | H | York City | 2–0 | ||
| 29 Dec 1990 | 1990–91 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 0–4 | ||
| 6 Apr 1991 | 1990–91 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 0–0 | ||
| 21 Sep 1991 | 1991–92 | Fourth Division | A | York City | 2–2 | ||
| 18 Apr 1992 | 1991–92 | Fourth Division | H | York City | 2–1 | ||
| 29 Aug 1992 | 1992–93 | Third Division | A | York City | 0–4 | ||
| 26 Jan 1993 | 1992–93 | Third Division | H | York City | 3–0 | Karl Connolly 1, Steve Watkin 78, Steve Watkin 88 | |
| 27 Nov 1993 | 1993–94 | Second Division | H | York City | 1–1 | Gary Bennett 14 | |
| 7 May 1994 | 1993–94 | Second Division | A | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 1 Feb 1995 | 1994–95 | Second Division | A | York City | 1–0 | ||
| 8 Apr 1995 | 1994–95 | Second Division | H | York City | 1–1 | Karl Connolly 88 | |
| 7 Oct 1995 | 1995–96 | Second Division | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 30 Mar 1996 | 1995–96 | Second Division | H | York City | 2–3 | ||
| 14 Dec 1996 | 1996–97 | Second Division | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 15 Mar 1997 | 1996–97 | Second Division | H | York City | 0–0 | ||
| 13 Dec 1997 | 1997–98 | Second Division | A | York City | 0–1 | ||
| 13 Apr 1998 | 1997–98 | Second Division | H | York City | 1–2 | Mark Wilson 65 | |
| 12 Sep 1998 | 1998–99 | Second Division | A | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 5 Dec 1998 | 1998–99 | FA Cup | H | York City | 2–1 | ||
| 20 Feb 1999 | 1998–99 | Second Division | H | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 29 Oct 2002 | 2002–03 | Third Division | A | York City | 1–1 | Stephen Roberts 8 | |
| 22 Mar 2003 | 2002–03 | Third Division | H | York City | 1–1 | ||
| 3 Dec 2022 | 2022–23 | Other | A | York City | 1–1 | Thomas O'Connor 88 | 7,145 |
| 25 Mar 2023 | 2022–23 | Other | H | York City | 3–0 | R.Whitley 42, Sam Dalby 80, Elliot Lee 90+2 | 10,161 |