Arsenal have played Rotherham Town 6 times in competitive football, winning 3, drawing 2 and losing 1, first meeting on 13 Nov 1893 and most recently on 26 Oct 1895. Every meeting is listed below.
| Date | Season | Competition | Venue | Opponent | Score | Scorers | Att |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Nov 1893 | 1893–94 | Second Division | H | Rotherham Town | 3–0 | Walter Shaw, Walter Shaw, Arthur Elliott | |
| 6 Feb 1894 | 1893–94 | Second Division | A | Rotherham Town | 1–1 | Arthur Worrall | |
| 20 Oct 1894 | 1894–95 | Second Division | A | Rotherham Town | 2–1 | James Boyle, James Henderson | |
| 9 Feb 1895 | 1894–95 | Second Division | H | Rotherham Town | 1–1 | William Sharpe | |
| 5 Oct 1895 | 1895–96 | Second Division | H | Rotherham Town | 5–0 | Caesar Jenkyns, Samuel Mills, Peter Mortimer, Bob Gordon, Robert Buchanan | |
| 26 Oct 1895 | 1895–96 | Second Division | A | Rotherham Town | 0–3 |